Shaken, and Stirred.
Last night, I made dinner for the other two members of the Unholy Triumvirate. In preparation for their Ph.D. comps, I fed them brain food. Spinach salad with blood oranges, goat cheese, and almonds, grilled wild salmon with brown rice and curry sauce, and several glasses of wine to help them sleep. I sent them off well fed and hopefully a little less stressed about their written exams, which are today and tomorrow.
So, slightly tipsy I sat down at my computer, where I came across something that left me rattled and sad. In one of the most beautiful pieces of writing I have read in a long time, my friend said goodbye to graduate school. He entered the program at the same time I did, in the same area— one of only a handful of eighteenth century graduate students. Despite the fact that we entered at the same time, he was two years ahead of me in the program, having already received his M.A. elsewhere. We have read together, taken classes together, and gossiped together. He is a true intellectual, who came to graduate school later in life with a real passion for his work and ideas. He is intimidatingly well read. He is, in my mind, what a graduate student should be.
And now, he too is leaving. And I shouldn't care. After all, I am leaving.
But I do.

4 Comments:
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Amy--
Thank you for your very kind words. For once, I am speechless. All I can say is that I truly appreciate your unsolicited praise both here and on my blog.
Professors--the good ones--will tell you that you should never read your rec letters, the idea being that you'll be staggered by the extraordinary measures taken to secure your place in a grad program (or in line for a grant or scholarship or whatever). I feel the same way about your comments: I feel honored that such a fiercely intelligent person has said these things about me, but at the same time I am both staggered and embarrassed by an assessment of my worth culled from those moments in which I am at my very best.
I wish you well, as well. I probably haven't said that enough, probably because I consider you a true polymath: you will--and already have--risen to excellence in several different environments. If anyone reading this thinks that that I'm speaking in platitudes, just google:
"Amy Novak" debate
Or, go here.
Like my pal Monstro, you've always seemed so absolutely put together and confident in your own abilities that praise from me would be...well...useless. But I'll say it anyways, and you can add it to the heap of better-voiced praise you have--and are yet--to receive: I wish you the best in your future endeavors and I sincerely believe that you will perform far and above your peers in whatever endeavors you choose to pursue.
Okay, so maybe I wasn't completely speechless.
[I'm also posting a copy of this comment on my blog]
I just re-read this comment. There are a gajillion grammatical errors there! Sorry that my hastily--furiously--written comment comes across as the musings of a simpleton.
By the way, the "go here" link didn't seem to work on that last post. Readers can find evidence of your exploits here:
http://www.rochester.edu/pr/Currents/V30/V30SI/story04.html
Jason,
It is an absolute impossibility that anything you write could come across as the musings of a simpleton. Quite simply put, you are an amazing writer.
The interesting thing about unsolicited praise is that, unlike a recommendation letter, is that it is uniquely sincere. You wrote: "I am both staggered and embarrassed by an assessment of my worth culled from those moments in which I am at my very best." I disagree that I have only seen you at your very best. I've seen you at least once a week for the better part of two years. The law of averages dictates that I must have seen you on an off day now and again. Or, you have been at your very best so consistently and for so long that perhaps your very best is just your normal state of being.
It may be a good thing that the writhing neurotic mass of insecurities that lives inside each of us is not readily apparent to the rest of the world, but we shouldn't live our lives thinking that those insecurities— those weakness— are what really matter.
You've got the things that really matter and I'm looking forward to seeing what you do with them.
~Amy
P.S. Now, I am calling a halt to our praise-fest before things get to gooey. I am already blushing furiously and my head is swelling from your previous comments-- no more. (However, The floggings will continue until morale improves.)
Post a Comment
<< Home